You’d think the scary part of renting a car after 65 is the driving. It’s not, because the costly trouble usually starts at the counter, before the engine ever turns on.
Age rules, toll fees, insurance gaps and discount fine print quietly drain travel budgets, and the same handful of mistakes keep surfacing in advice from AAA, the FTC and consumer guides. A few can end a trip before it begins, and the one waiting at #1 stopped an 81-year-old cold at a desk in Italy.
#15 – Skipping Senior Discounts Entirely

The easiest money on the table is the discount nobody asks about.
Hertz offers discounts of up to 20% through its 50 Plus Program, and Hertz and Thrifty both run senior programs for renters 50 and over.
AARP membership also opens deals at Avis, Budget and Payless. The biggest savings come from booking Avis or Budget directly, choosing Pay Now and entering your AARP number.
Skip that step and you pay the public rate.
Fast Facts
- Hertz 50 Plus: discounts of up to 20%.
- Hertz and Thrifty: senior programs for renters 50 and over.
- AARP deals: Avis, Budget and Payless.
- Best results: book direct, choose Pay Now, enter your AARP number.
But one assumption about AARP trips up even longtime members, and it’s waiting in #14…
#14 – Assuming Your AARP Card Works at Every Counter

Your AARP card has no pull at one of the biggest names in the business.
Hertz does not have a direct AARP discount. Its cars show up on the AARP portal, but only for comparison pricing.
The portal lists other major brands too, but exclusive AARP discounts may not apply there. One senior-savings site even calls Hertz’s own 50+ program a separate and sometimes better option.
Loyalty can be expensive. And the next mistake hides inside a single checkbox…
#13 – Choosing “Pay Later” Without Doing the Math

One click can move your discount by five percentage points.
At Avis and Budget, AARP members can get up to 35% off base rates when paying at booking, or 30% when paying at pickup. Sources differ slightly by brand and date, so treat those percentages as ceilings.
The discount applies only to the base rate. That’s the core time-and-mileage charge, not the whole bill.
Money isn’t the only thing that slips by at booking. Next up is a line item many couples pay for twice…
#12 – Mishandling the Second Driver

Adding a spouse to the contract can quietly add a daily charge.
Additional-driver fees are a common line item, and the rules vary by company. AARP rates at Avis and Budget include a free additional driver, according to one summary of the member benefits.
The opposite mistake is worse. Most rental agreements restrict who may drive, and letting an unlisted spouse take the wheel can put your coverage at risk.
Ask the agent to list everyone who might drive. It takes ten seconds. But the next mistake involves a refund you might think you’re earning…
#11 – Returning the Car Early to “Save Money”

Bringing the car back ahead of schedule can backfire.
The FTC says returning a car more than 24 hours early can trigger a charge.1 The rate you were quoted may assume the full rental period.
Running late isn’t safer. AAA suggests checking whether it’s cheaper to pay the late fee or extend the rental for another day.1
Early or late, the real damage often happens before you leave the lot. And that leads to #10…
#10 – Skipping the Walkaround Photos

The most valuable two minutes of your rental happen before you drive away.
Photograph every panel, each wheel, the windshield and the interior. Grab the fuel gauge and odometer too.
Damage missing from your paperwork can end up billed to you. Your own photos may be the only neutral record you’ll have.
Pictures protect the outside of the car. But what about the part you actually have to operate? That’s #9…
#9 – Driving Off Without Learning the Controls

Today’s rental fleets can feel like a different planet from the car in your garage.
You may be handed a car you’ve never driven.
Worth Knowing
- Push-button starts and electronic parking brakes are common on newer models.
- Touchscreen-heavy dashboards can bury basics like defrost and wipers.
- Confirm the fuel type before you leave the lot.
- You can ask for a different car before you drive off.
The mistake is figuring it out in traffic. Spend five minutes in the lot setting the seat, mirrors, lights, wipers and reverse.
If something feels confusing, walk back inside and ask for a different car. Next come the insurance mistakes, starting with the one that costs the most at the counter…
#8 – Buying the Counter Waiver Out of Habit

That pricey waiver may duplicate protection already in your wallet.
If you pay with a card that offers rental car benefits, you may be able to skip the agency’s collision damage waiver. The catch: you must reserve and pay for the entire rental with that card and decline the rental company’s CDW.2
Not everyone agrees on skipping it. Some renters happily pay for the waiver so they never have to file a claim themselves, and the point is to choose on purpose, not under pressure.
Declining the waiver is only half the decision. The next mistake is about who pays first…
#7 – Assuming Card Coverage Pays First

Primary and secondary coverage are not the same thing.
Primary coverage steps in before your own insurance policy. Secondary coverage only kicks in after other coverage is exhausted.3
In one audit of 155 cards, 91 had rental coverage and only 25 of those offered primary CDW. The Amex Platinum, for instance, gives secondary coverage up to $75,000, with an upgrade to primary costing up to $25 per rental.
Several U.S. cards are secondary at home but primary abroad.
Even perfect card coverage leaves one enormous gap. It’s #6…
#6 – Believing Your Card Covers Liability

The biggest financial risk of a rental isn’t the car.
Card rental coverage generally doesn’t include liability or medical coverage. It reimburses loss or damage to the rental vehicle itself, not injuries or property damage you cause to someone else.3
Quick Compare
- Usually covered by the card: loss or damage to the rental vehicle itself.
- Usually not covered by the card: liability, medical costs, and injuries or property damage you cause to others.
That liability usually falls to your personal auto insurance, which typically extends to rentals in your home country, or to supplemental coverage from the rental company.2 Abroad, the rules may differ, so verify before you fly.
No car of your own? The Insurance Information Institute recommends a non-owner liability policy if you rent frequently.
Now let’s talk about the number on the booking screen, because it isn’t the number on your bill. That’s #5…
#5 – Trusting the Advertised Price

The rate you see online is rarely the rate you pay.
The FTC’s 2025 Junk Fees Rule requires upfront total pricing for hotels, short-term rentals and live event tickets, but car rentals are explicitly excluded. So the advertised rate isn’t guaranteed to match the final bill.
Airports add their own charge. Airport concession recovery runs 10 to 15% of the rental cost, or a flat daily fee.
Many travelers see airport pickup as the obvious choice, but others argue a neighborhood branch is the smarter play even after a short taxi ride.
But the fee that really stings is one you only meet after you’ve left the lot. It’s #4…
#4 – Saying Yes to the Toll Package

A few toll booths can turn into a bill bigger than the tolls themselves.
Rental companies often enroll drivers automatically and add a convenience fee, typically $4 to $10 per day on top of the actual toll cost. AAA puts the transponder fee at about $3 to $5 per day, often capped at $15 to $20 per rental period.
Some programs charge every day, toll or no toll. Under the Avis e-Toll Unlimited program, you pay a daily fee whether or not you incur any actual tolls.
One senator asked the FTC to investigate after finding some convenience charges exceeded 500% of the toll itself. That request is noted in a 2026 fee guide.
- Ask whether the fee is daily or only on toll days.
- Ask what the per-rental cap is.
Bringing your own device sounds like the perfect fix. But there’s a trap, and it’s #3…
#3 – Bringing Your Own Transponder the Wrong Way

Packing your E-ZPass isn’t enough on its own.
AAA advises making sure the rental’s built-in transponder is covered, usually by a sliding cover, so the booth reads your personal one. You also need to register the rental car’s details on your transponder account.4
Skip those steps and you can pay twice. One source says toll violations can bring an administrative fee of $15 to $50 on top of the original toll.
Reviewers on ConsumerAffairs describe being billed despite using their own device, though those are complaints, not verified findings.
Now for the last two mistakes. They decide whether you get a car at all, and the next one trips up even careful planners…
#2 – Trusting the Brand Name Instead of the Branch

A famous logo on the website doesn’t guarantee that branch’s rules.
As corporate policy, the big three global rental groups don’t set an age maximum. But smaller European rental companies do, as do some locally owned stations of the global brands.5
Even in the U.S., individual franchise owners may set their own rules despite a company-wide policy. Age limits are more likely at smaller locations than at big airport ones.
Which brings us to the mistake that can cancel a whole itinerary. It’s #1…
#1 – Assuming Age Doesn’t Matter Abroad

At a rental desk in Italy, an 81-year-old traveler found out the hard way.
SmarterTravel describes a senior who arranged a car at Bari Airport and was turned away on arrival, even though he’d entered his age during booking. The desk said it couldn’t rent to travelers 75 or over.5
Ireland has no legal maximum age, but each company sets its own limit. AutoSlash lists the following limits.
Fast Facts
| Country | Reported age limit |
|---|---|
| Bulgaria | 70 |
| Croatia | 70 |
| Greece | 75 |
| Ireland | 75 |
| Mexico (general) | 75 |
Policies also vary by company, and the sources don’t always agree.
- Hertz in the UK accepts drivers 75 to 79 with a good driving record and a doctor’s statement.
- One 2026 guide says Sixt in Ireland requires a printed medical certificate dated within three months of pickup.
- Sources even conflict: Auto Europe lists no maximum age in Italy, yet a Bari rental desk applied a 75 cutoff.6
An older forum thread said documents had to arrive at least five working days before the rental, and deadlines may have changed since then. Email the exact branch, in writing, before you pay for anything.
Most of these mistakes cost money, but the age rules abroad can cost you the whole car. Limits of 70 or 75 turn up in several countries, and they’re set by individual companies, not by law.
At home, the biggest leaks are quieter: daily toll fees, card coverage that isn’t primary, and no card that covers liability. AARP deals only work at certain brands, and the advertised price is never the final one.
Fees and age policies change often, so confirm age rules, insurance and fees in writing before you travel. Which of these mistakes has cost you the most at a rental counter?
Bonus: The Insider Move Nobody Tells You

Treat your reservation as a draft, not a final purchase. Rental prices move constantly, and a booking with free cancellation lets you take advantage of every drop.
- Step 1: As soon as your dates are set, book a free-cancellation rate with your AARP or 50 Plus code. Prepay only if the cancellation terms are as flexible as the pay-at-pickup option.
- Step 2: Re-run the same search every week or two, and again in the final few days before pickup. A free tracking service such as AutoSlash can also watch an existing reservation and alert you to cheaper rates.
- Step 3: When you find a lower total, book the new rate first, then cancel the old one. Never cancel first.
- Step 4: Compare the all-in total with taxes and fees, not the headline daily rate, and confirm the discount code carried over.
Save the cancellation confirmation email for every reservation you drop. If a stray charge shows up later, that email is your proof.
- AAA Rental Car Tips: https://mwg.aaa.com/via/car/things-know-rent-car
- State Farm Card Rental Coverage: https://www.statefarm.com/simple-insights/auto-and-vehicles/credit-card-rental-car-insurance-benefits-explained
- Capital One Rental Insurance: https://www.capitalone.com/learn-grow/money-management/credit-cards-rental-car-insurance/
- AAA Rental Car Tolls: https://cluballiance.aaa.com/the-extra-mile/advice/travel/avoid-costly-mistakes-when-paying-tolls-in-a-rental-car
- SmarterTravel Senior Rentals Europe: https://www.smartertravel.com/age-to-drive-in-europe-for-traveling-seniors/
- Enterprise Bari Airport Policy: https://www.enterprise.com/en/car-rental-locations/it/bari-airport-llad.html






