Travelbinger
TravelbingerTravel deals, guides and hacks
Travel News
Trip Planner
Sign In
Travel tips

15 Fees Experienced Travelers Decline at an American Rental Counter That Everybody Else Simply Pays

Share:
Expert reviewed
Anna Lena KuhnKatherine Woodward Ramer

By Written by Anna Lena Kuhn

·

Edited by Katherine Woodward Ramer

Cited 7 sourcesUpdated Nov 16, 2026· 15 min read
DetailsFull details

Cited Sources (7)

Jump to bottom list ↓
  1. Kiplinger Rental Car Fees(kiplinger.com)
  2. AAA Hertz Member Benefits(discounts.aaa.com)
  3. Additional Driver Fees 2026(myrentright.com)
  4. Avis e-Toll Services(avis.com)
  5. Avis Fees & Taxes FAQ(avis.com)
  6. AAA Rental Car Tolls(cluballiance.aaa.com)
  7. State Farm Card Coverage(statefarm.com)
Author:Anna Lena Kuhn

Global Experience Sharer

Lena has been to over 30 countries and loves sharing her experiences with the world.

Editor:Katherine Woodward Ramer

Editorial Specialist

Checks destination facts and source links before a story is published.

Published November 16, 2026 · Updated November 16, 2026 · 15 min readRead our editorial policy.
15 Fees Experienced Travelers Decline at an American Rental Counter That Everybody Else Simply Pays
Add as a preferredsource on Google

You booked a car at what looked like a fair price. Across 100 U.S. airports, the average daily rental rate was $62.25 in a December 2025 report from Cheap Car Rental.1 Then the counter screen starts adding lines, and Kiplinger’s rental-fee roundup warns you could end up paying double the daily rate unless you just say no.

That gap between the price you booked and the total you’re handed is what this list is about. Fifteen add-ons come up often enough to be worth rehearsing a polite refusal for, and a few vanish with a membership card or a closed plastic box. One is the biggest charge on the screen, and it is one of only two you shouldn’t wave away by reflex. First, though, comes the weakest case on the menu: a navigation screen you already carry in your pocket.

#15 – The Navigation Screen Already in Your Pocket

#15 - The Navigation Screen Already in Your Pocket (Image Credits: Photo)
#15 – The Navigation Screen Already in Your Pocket (Image Credits: Photo)

The rental GPS unit is the easiest charge to refuse, because your phone does the same job. The counter script often mentions areas without cell service, which is a fair worry with a free answer. Download the offline map for your destination before you leave home.

That way, a daily fee never gets to stack on top of everything else on the agreement. Your phone also has an edge over the rented unit: Google Maps lets you choose to avoid toll roads along your route, and that setting matters once you see what toll programs charge. A phone doesn’t tow a car, though, and that is where the roadside add-on makes its pitch.

#14 – The Roadside Plan You May Already Own

#14 - The Roadside Plan You May Already Own (Image Credits: Photo)
#14 – The Roadside Plan You May Already Own (Image Credits: Photo)

If you belong to AAA, or your auto insurer or credit card includes roadside help, the rental company’s daily roadside add-on pays for the same tow twice. Look at the cards in your wallet before the trip. You’ll usually know within a couple of minutes whether the counter is selling you something you already have.

Rental agreements normally list a number to call if the car breaks down, so declining does not leave you stranded on a dark highway shoulder. Read yours before you drive off the lot. The same AAA card also waives an extra-driver fee at Hertz, which comes up further down.

Worth Knowing

  • Check three places first: your AAA card, your auto insurer and your credit card.
  • Your rental agreement normally lists a breakdown number to call.
  • Read that number before you leave the lot, not on the shoulder.
  • A AAA card can do double duty at Hertz by waiving the extra-driver fee.2

#13 – The Bigger Car Offered as a Favor

#13 - The Bigger Car Offered as a Favor (Image Credits: Image)
#13 – The Bigger Car Offered as a Favor (Image Credits: Image)

An upgrade offer arrives sounding like a gift, and it is a sale. You can usually say no and keep the car you reserved. The online reservation is the price you agreed to, and the counter is the most expensive place to renegotiate it.

Some upgrades are fair deals, such as a long drive with four suitcases and two grandchildren. But decide that at home, with the rates in front of you, rather than at 11 p.m. in a slow line. A larger engine also changes what a tank of gas costs, and electric cars have their own version of that bill.

#12 – The EV Charging Package for a Car You Can Just Plug In

#12 - The EV Charging Package for a Car You Can Just Plug In (Image Credits: Photo)
#12 – The EV Charging Package for a Car You Can Just Plug In (Image Credits: Photo)

As rental fleets add electric cars, some counters now sell a charging-management add-on. One guide puts these fees at $5 to $20 a day, nominally covering charging network access or return-charging services. That is a daily price for something you may need once or twice.

Try This: Before you leave the lot, take a photo of the dashboard showing the charge or fuel level, plus any scuffs or stains. Noting a dirty interior on the contract before you drive off protects you from a cleaning charge later.

In most cases you can decline the package and charge the car yourself at a standard public charging station. Charging costs follow what you use, while a package follows the calendar. A short trip with a single charge is where the package looks worst.

#11 – The $4.69 Accident Coverage That Hides in Plain Sight

#11 - The $4.69 Accident Coverage That Hides in Plain Sight (Image Credits: Editorial photo)
#11 – The $4.69 Accident Coverage That Hides in Plain Sight (Image Credits: Editorial photo)

This line looks harmless because it is small. Sixt lists personal accident coverage at $4.69 a day in a booking simulation at LAX in August 2026, covering personal injury to you and your passengers during the rental. Small daily charges are the easiest to accept without a second look.

If you carry health insurance, you probably already have a way to pay for treatment after a car accident, and a daily fee buys a second layer on top of it. This one looks skippable once you’ve confirmed what your own health policy and any travel coverage pay for. Passengers are also the reason for the next charge, since a grandchild needs a seat the counter will gladly rent.

#10 – The Child Seat Rented by the Day

#10 - The Child Seat Rented by the Day (Image Credits: Accompanying image)
#10 – The Child Seat Rented by the Day (Image Credits: Accompanying image)

Bringing your own child seat is the usual advice when you can, and for grandparents flying in to see family it is worth planning for. Most major U.S. airlines let you check a car seat without a fee, though your airline’s website will confirm its own rule. You also know where your own seat has been, which you can’t say about one pulled from a rental company shelf.

State laws require young children to ride in an approved restraint, so the savings come from bringing the seat and never from leaving it out. If the flight makes that impractical, ask the counter for the seat’s price in writing before you agree. It will be charged for every day of the rental.

At a Glance

  • Bring your own: most major U.S. airlines let you check a car seat without a fee.
  • Know the rule: state laws require young children to ride in an approved restraint.
  • If you rent: get the price in writing before you agree.
  • Remember: the seat is charged for every day of the rental.

#9 – Prepaid Fuel That Rewards an Empty Tank

#9 - Prepaid Fuel That Rewards an Empty Tank (Image Credits: Accompanying image)
#9 – Prepaid Fuel That Rewards an Empty Tank (Image Credits: Accompanying image)

Prepaid fuel is sold as convenience. You pay for a full tank at the counter and are encouraged to return the car as empty as possible. Since the price covers a whole tank, any fuel left when you return the car is typically paid for and not credited.

By The Numbers: Sixt’s prepaid fuel was $77.70 as a one-time charge at LAX in an August 2026 booking simulation. Amounts vary by location, so compare it with what the station near your drop-off charges for a fill-up.

The option makes financial sense only if you’re confident you’ll return the car nearly empty and in a hurry. For an ordinary trip, filling up a few miles from the drop-off and keeping the receipt wins. Fuel is a charge you can settle with a receipt, while the next one depends on who is sitting in the passenger seat.

#8 – The Extra-Driver Fee That Spouses Often Skip

#8 - The Extra-Driver Fee That Spouses Often Skip (Image Credits: Image)
#8 – The Extra-Driver Fee That Spouses Often Skip (Image Credits: Image)

Adding a second driver can cost real money, yet Enterprise, Alamo, National, Avis, Budget and Fox all waive the fee automatically for a spouse. Hertz waives it for a spouse or domestic partner if you’re a Gold+ Rewards member, and that program is free to join before you book. Without the waiver, Hertz’s published rate as of October 2026 is $13.50 per day per additional driver, capped at $216 per rental per driver.3

Did You Know: New York state law caps additional driver fees on car rentals at $5 per day, so a fee quoted for other states may not apply there.

Sixt is the exception. It has no spouse waiver at any loyalty tier, though some states require one by law. A waived fee also does not waive the young-driver surcharge, which still applies if the additional driver is under 25. The waiver covers a spouse, but a friend or adult child pays full price unless a membership steps in.

#7 – The Extra-Driver Fee a Membership Card Erases

#7 - The Extra-Driver Fee a Membership Card Erases (Image Credits: Image)
#7 – The Extra-Driver Fee a Membership Card Erases (Image Credits: Image)

For a second driver who isn’t a spouse, memberships do the work. Hertz waives the fee for drivers who are AAA members, and for the spouse or domestic partner of a AAA member.2 3 At Avis and Budget, AARP rates include an additional driver at no cost.

Costco members get the fee waived on Avis and Budget rentals in the U.S. Booking through Costco Travel typically waives one additional driver fee with Alamo, Enterprise, Avis and Budget in the U.S. and Canada.

Insider Tip: Hertz, Enterprise and National say additional drivers must be present with a valid license. Bring the second driver to the pickup counter, or the waiver won’t help if that person takes the wheel.

If you already hold an AARP or AAA card, checking the perk takes a minute. At Hertz, where the fee runs up to a $216 cap, the AAA waiver saves the most on long trips. A membership bought only to cover a three-day rental is hard to justify.

#6 – The Unlimited Toll Plan That Bills You Every Single Day

#6 - The Unlimited Toll Plan That Bills You Every Single Day (Image Credits: Image)
#6 – The Unlimited Toll Plan That Bills You Every Single Day (Image Credits: Image)

The flat toll plan is the expensive end of the toll menu. Avis e-Toll Unlimited charges $10.99 to $25.99 per day, depending on checkout location, for each day of the rental whether or not you incur any tolls. Weekly it tops out at $54.95 to $181.93, and Budget posts the same structure.4

Fox’s version carries a second trap. Its PlatePass runs $13.99 per day, and a toll admin fee of $15 per event applies if you pass a toll without a pass. Unless every day of your trip is built around toll roads, the unlimited plan costs more than the tolls ever will.

Declining it doesn’t make a toll disappear, though. A cashless gantry still bills the car, and the rental company adds its own fee.5 6

Quick Compare

  • Avis e-Toll Unlimited: $10.99 to $25.99 per day, every day, tolls or not.
  • Fox PlatePass: $13.99 per day, plus a $15 admin fee per event if you pass a toll without a pass.
  • Avis standard e-Toll: $6.95 only on days you incur a toll, up to $34.95 per rental period, plus the toll itself.

#5 – The Convenience Fee That Turns a $2 Toll Into $8.95

#5 - The Convenience Fee That Turns a $2 Toll Into $8.95 (Image Credits: Photo)
#5 – The Convenience Fee That Turns a $2 Toll Into $8.95 (Image Credits: Photo)

Avis’s standard e-Toll charges a $6.95 convenience fee for each day you incur a toll, up to $34.95 per rental period.5 The toll itself comes on top. The toll is charged to the car, then Avis works out who the renter was and bills them for the toll plus the fee.4 On that schedule, a $2 toll becomes $8.95.

Why It Works: Closing the transponder’s shield box hides it so the toll plaza can’t see it. Without a signal from the rental’s device, the fee program has nothing to trigger on.

You have options. You can use your own toll tag if you register the rental’s license plate with it, and remove that plate when you’re done. Budget lists the other routes: pay cash, pay the toll authority directly online, or avoid electronic toll roads.

Cash is not always accepted, since many states are modernizing their systems. Tolls are the part of the bill you steer from the driver’s seat, but the airport’s own charges are set before you reach the counter.

#4 – The Airport Charges You Can Only Dodge by Skipping the Terminal

#4 - The Airport Charges You Can Only Dodge by Skipping the Terminal (Image Credits: Editorial photo)
#4 – The Airport Charges You Can Only Dodge by Skipping the Terminal (Image Credits: Editorial photo)

This is the odd entry, because you can’t decline it at the counter. Airport concession recovery fees, customer facility charges, local taxes and vehicle license fees are commonly built into airport rentals. Airport taxes and fees apply to every rental at every airport location, regardless of supplier. The only way out is to pick the car up somewhere else.

Renting from an off-airport location can sometimes reduce the airport-specific fees, though you will need a way to get there. That trade is overrated for a short trip with heavy luggage, where a rideshare to the lot can eat the savings and the patience. It works better on longer rentals, and the comparison that matters is the all-in total, since the quoted daily rate is only the start.1

Why It Stands Out

  • It’s the one entry on this list with no way to say no at the counter.
  • The charges are commonly built in: concession recovery, facility charges, local taxes and license fees.
  • They apply at every airport location, whichever supplier you pick.
  • Off-airport pickup is the only escape, and only the all-in total tells you if it pays.

#3 – The Protection Package With the Reassuring Name

#3 - The Protection Package With the Reassuring Name (Image Credits: Image)
#3 – The Protection Package With the Reassuring Name (Image Credits: Image)

Rental menus now bundle coverage under comforting names. Sixt’s online prices at LAX in August 2026 started at $6.57 a day for Cover The Car, $15.05 for Cover The Car & Liability, and $25.46 for Peace of Mind. The jump from the first to the last is the price of adding layers you may already own elsewhere.

Insider Tip: At Sixt, changing your selection at the counter makes the discount disappear and you pay the full rack rate. If you do want coverage there, choose it online before you arrive.

A Kiplinger writer notes that what rental companies sell is usually a waiver, not insurance, which lets you pay to waive responsibility for damage to the car.1 Buy the pieces you need, not the bundle named for how it makes you feel.

Related Stories From Travelbinger

  • 15 Car Rental Fees That Vanish for Drivers Over 60 Who Simply Enquire at the Counter
  • 15 Hotel Fees That Vanish for Guests Over 60 Who Simply Enquire at Check-In
  • 13 Fees at American Airports That Experienced Travelers Never Actually End Up Paying At All

A bundle that includes liability deserves a closer look, since liability is the one thing a credit card won’t cover.

#2 – The Liability Add-On Your Card Will Not Replace

#2 - The Liability Add-On Your Card Will Not Replace (Image Credits: Editorial photo)
#2 – The Liability Add-On Your Card Will Not Replace (Image Credits: Editorial photo)

Sixt lists supplemental liability insurance at $13.65 a day at LAX in the same August 2026 simulation. This is where the card advice found everywhere has a limit. Card coverage handles damage or theft of the rental, but won’t cover damage you may cause to other vehicles or the property of others.7 It also does not cover necessary medical treatment for you, your passengers or pedestrians.

Editor’s Note: Of the charges on this list, this is one of two where a careless no can cost real money later. A call to your insurance agent before the trip settles it.

If you own a car, ask your insurer whether your liability coverage extends to rentals; many policies do, but yours may differ. If you don’t own a car, this may be the one line worth buying, because nothing else is standing behind you. Damage to the rental car itself is a separate line, and it is the priciest on the screen.

#1 – The Damage Waiver That Can Double Your Bill

#1 - The Damage Waiver That Can Double Your Bill (Image Credits: Editorial photo)
#1 – The Damage Waiver That Can Double Your Bill (Image Credits: Editorial photo)

The collision or loss damage waiver is the biggest charge and the one agents push hardest. Insurance at the counter can sometimes double the cost of your rental. Fox lists its loss damage waiver at $11 to $32.99 a day, which adds up fast over a week.

But it isn’t always wasteful. A waiver can be worth the cost if you have neither your own auto policy nor credit card benefits to pay for damage to a rental.

Try This: Call your card’s benefits line and ask three things: whether coverage is primary or secondary, which vehicle types are excluded, and how many days it covers. Save the answers on your phone for the counter.

The card route has rules. Coverage usually applies when you use your card to pay for the rental and decline the rental company’s waiver. The Chase Sapphire Preferred offers primary coverage, while the Platinum Card from American Express offers secondary.

Upgrading Amex to primary costs up to $25 per rental and requires enrolling in Premium Car Rental Protection. With no personal auto insurance, secondary card coverage generally becomes primary for collision. Coverage also has a day limit, with primary card coverage commonly capped at around 31 days, so a long rental needs a check before you decline.

Almost every refusal above got easier for one reason: the question was answered at home before anyone asked it. Your auto policy, your credit card, a AAA or AARP card, a toll tag and a phone with offline maps decide more of the final bill than the agent ever will.

The charge worth a real conversation is the damage waiver, and that conversation belongs to your own insurer, not a stranger at a counter. Which card in your wallet, whether AAA, AARP, Costco or a credit card, has actually saved you money on a rental, and how?

Sources:

  1. Kiplinger Rental Car Fees: https://www.kiplinger.com/personal-finance/spending/rental-car-fees-to-avoid
  2. AAA Hertz Member Benefits: https://discounts.aaa.com/hertz
  3. Additional Driver Fees 2026: https://myrentright.com/tips/additional-driver-fees
  4. Avis e-Toll Services: https://www.avis.com/en/products-and-services/services/avis-e-toll
  5. Avis Fees & Taxes FAQ: https://www.avis.com/en/customer-service/faqs/usa/ai-faqs
  6. AAA Rental Car Tolls: https://cluballiance.aaa.com/the-extra-mile/advice/travel/avoid-costly-mistakes-when-paying-tolls-in-a-rental-car
  7. State Farm Card Coverage: https://www.statefarm.com/simple-insights/auto-and-vehicles/credit-card-rental-car-insurance-benefits-explained

🔥 Would you like to save this?

We’ll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later.

Anna Lena Kuhn

Anna Lena Kuhn

Lena has been to over 30 countries and loves sharing her experiences with the world.

View Profile & Articles
Katherine Woodward Ramer

Edited & reviewed by Katherine Woodward Ramer — Editorial Specialist

Expert reviewed

More from Anna Lena Kuhn

16 Things Shore Excursion Staff Know About an American Port That Never Reaches Any Brochure

16 Things Shore Excursion Staff Know About an American Port That Never Reaches Any Brochure

1 min read

17 Things Experienced Flyers Do at American Security That Nobody Standing Behind Them Has Worked Out

17 Things Experienced Flyers Do at American Security That Nobody Standing Behind Them Has Worked Out

1 min read

20 Expenses Travelers Over 60 Simply Stop Carrying Once They Understand the Rules Properly

20 Expenses Travelers Over 60 Simply Stop Carrying Once They Understand the Rules Properly

1 min read

15 Arrangements Cruise Desks Make Quietly for Guests Over 70 Who Are Sailing Without Any Company

15 Arrangements Cruise Desks Make Quietly for Guests Over 70 Who Are Sailing Without Any Company

1 min read

Latest News

Fresh travel updates

16 Things Shore Excursion Staff Know About an American Port That Never Reaches Any Brochure

16 Things Shore Excursion Staff Know About an American Port That Never Reaches Any Brochure

Matthias Binder·Nov 16
17 Things Experienced Flyers Do at American Security That Nobody Standing Behind Them Has Worked Out

17 Things Experienced Flyers Do at American Security That Nobody Standing Behind Them Has Worked Out

Stefan Brand·Nov 16
20 Expenses Travelers Over 60 Simply Stop Carrying Once They Understand the Rules Properly

20 Expenses Travelers Over 60 Simply Stop Carrying Once They Understand the Rules Properly

Samanta Brown·Nov 16
15 Arrangements Cruise Desks Make Quietly for Guests Over 70 Who Are Sailing Without Any Company

15 Arrangements Cruise Desks Make Quietly for Guests Over 70 Who Are Sailing Without Any Company

Matthias Binder·Nov 16
View All News

Stay Updated

Get the latest travel news delivered to your inbox

Stay Inspired

Get travel inspiration, guides, and exclusive deals delivered to your inbox.

Travelbinger
TravelbingerTRAVEL DEALS, GUIDES AND HACKS

Discover the world through the eyes of seasoned travel experts. From breaking news to hand-picked destination guides, we bring you the stories that matter. Join our community for exclusive member deals and authentic inspiration for your next journey.

Deals

  • All Deals
  • Beach Holidays
  • City Breaks
  • Luxury Hotels
  • Last Minute

Popular Destinations

  • Europe
  • Asia
  • North America
  • South America
  • Africa

Company

  • About Us
  • Travel News
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

This website contains affiliate links to trusted partners.

© 2026 Travelbinger. All rights reserved.

Secure payment with:
Visa
MC
PayPal
Klarna